jmtandem

carson city nv

Senior Member

Joined: 01/18/2006

View Profile

Offline
|
Keith,
Sounds to me from your response to the "80 percent rule" question, that those towing need to know thet weights they are towing. How many have weighed their trailer, weighed their tongue and then weighed the payload including themselves for the truck's load? I would suspect not that many. More interesting and a disservice to the RV community are the sales tactics of only talking in terms of dry weights. The only time that trailer is at 'dry weight' is taking it home the first time.
Having questioned the eighty percent rule and agree totally with you about not knowing exactly what somebody's trailer really weighs, I don't send a boy to do a man's job. I tow a Pacific Coachworks 299bhs Tango trailer with a turbo diesel one-ton truck. Needless to say, it works very well. It goes without saying I don't 'fall on my face' climbing hills. And I even have a tongue scale to be sure I am in the 13 percent ball park. While I find little comfort in the 80 percent rule, I think that a 30+ foot trailer warrants considerable thought about what will be used to tow it. I like plenty of reserve power, rated sea level power at alitiude in the mountains that comes with a turbo diesel, and 19+ mpg not towing so I drive my signature truck. Everywhere I tow, there are long grades up to eight percent for as many as seven or eight miles without a break, leaving Reno for Sacramento is a mostly steady 35 mile climb to Truckee, then another eight miles of steeper clmbing to Donner summit at 7300 feet. Diesels are incredibly popular around here as the hills are flattened by the engine. It is the long long hills that really shows whether the manufacturer has the tow ratings dialed in or if it is sales hype.
'05 Dodge Cummins 4x4 dually 3500 white quadcab auto long bed airbags overload springs bumpers
|
lrak

MA

Senior Member

Joined: 11/03/2006

View Profile

|
Yahooligan wrote: There's more to towing than simple wheelbase to trailer length ratios and basic weights.
FWIW, my '05 Titan has a wheelbase of 139.8".
An '05 Ram 2500 regular cab long bed and quad-cab short bed have a wheelbase of 140.5". A whole 0.7" more. Guess what? The shorter-wheelbase trucks (Quad cab long bed are 160.5" wheelbase) have a higher tow capacity, much higher than my Titan.
So anyone that wants to go after a 1/2-ton truck owner for towing a trailer that's "too long" for its wheelbase has their work cut out for them
There's little work. They just copy and paste it over and over and over and it becomes gospel. Anyone challenging such a claim is an irresponsible danger to everyone on the road. ;-)
I have a question: How short is too short?
Tonight I'm towing a snowblower on a Long Chih 851T using an "even wimpier than 1/2 ton" "TOYota" "grocery getter". I think most of the weight police would reluctantly agree that -
- a class IV hitch might support 50lbs of tongue weight for 100 miles without failure
- my brakes are marginally capable of stopping the 400lb loaded trailer since I will be the only one in the truck ... but do weigh more than 150lbs
- at 8% of my towing capacity and 1000lbs under GVWR my insurance company will probably pay out for an accident
- my 140.9" wheelbase could be sufficient to safely control a 4.5' wide, 12' long, 2' high trailer
However, I often feel stressed while backing up a trailer that I can't see behind me and can't straighten out once I get more than about 25 degrees off straight line without pulling forward. Having the rear axle at the midway point between the front axle and trailer axle appears to be my limit. At this length ratio backing into loading docks intimidates me. I usually just line up the truck, get out, pick up the back end of the trailer, line it up manually, and back up in a straight line ... or borrow my wife's 102" WB compact car with the ball 16" behind the rear wheels that is a dangerous tow vehicle. ;-)
This trailer and similar models are used for homemade teardrop campers. I wonder how the weight police tow them with CrewCab dually pickups with 8' beds. I guess they really are better drivers.(?)
|
colochoclab

Arvada, Colorado

Senior Member

Joined: 05/24/2006

View Profile

Offline
|
Keith99RS wrote: JoeGood988 wrote: The Nissan Titan is a nice truck but it's still a lightweight pleasure truck. Towing is limited to ultralight trailers. When you get into trailers that are 30' or larger, you're heavier than the Nissan can safely handle. The true test is steep mountain grades of 8% or so....you will drop down to a crawl on a huge hill...then smoke the brakes coming down the other side. They don't put heavy duty brakes on either. Be safe, stay small until you can upgrade the truck to a 3/4 or 1 ton truck rated to safely haul what you need or desire.
TY for your uneducated post. The Titan towing is rated from 9100-9500lbs. I am towing a 30ft TT. Max GVWR of it is 8,000lbs. I tow usually a tad over 7500lbs. No issue with grade, no smoked brakes on the truck. 80,000 miles I am on my second set of rotors and pads. Your trailer brakes should be adjusted so your truck is not doing the stopping for both. Ford even states this in their tow guide. No truck is designed to stop itself and it's max tow load repeatedly with little or no assistance from the trailer. Please illustrate to us where I or others are unsafe if we are within design parameters of the truck.
Thanks once again Keith. Nail on the head!
-Lab
2008 Nissan Titan LE Crew 4x4
2006 Jayco JayFlight 29FBS
Equal-i-zer Hitch
Prodigy Brake Control
Member of clubtitan.org
"Hershey" & "Snickers" My Chocolate Labs!
"I asked God for true friends: He sent me 2 Labrador Retrievers."
|
ejbrandley

Entirely too young to be a

Senior Member

Joined: 06/18/2007

View Profile

Offline
|
ew ew can i join in here too?????
i'm towing a 8k pound tt that is 34 foot tip to tip i have a 700 lb tounge weight oh yeah and get this i'm towing it with a 1997 suburban that has upgraded tires rear gear and exhaust with 189k on the odometer original trans and engine am i over loaded ?? oh yeah and i have old fashion trunion bars with 1 friction sway bar
TV 1997 GMC SUBURBAN, 92 Mustang Rag Top
1986 34ft Nomad
Eric 33,Tammi 39,Anthony 14,Julia 12,Jason 11,Briana 8,Ashley 6,Robert 4
|
jmtandem

carson city nv

Senior Member

Joined: 01/18/2006

View Profile

Offline
|
ej,
Nice sarcasism but seriously your are under in your tongue weight. If you are really at 8000 pounds trailer weight, the tongue should be 10-15 percent or 800 to about 1200 pounds. Good luck and happy towing.
|
|
|
Keith99RS

Suffield, CT

Senior Member

Joined: 11/14/2005

View Profile

Online
|
jmtandem wrote: Keith,
Sounds to me from your response to the "80 percent rule" question, that those towing need to know thet weights they are towing. How many have weighed their trailer, weighed their tongue and then weighed the payload including themselves for the truck's load? I would suspect not that many. More interesting and a disservice to the RV community are the sales tactics of only talking in terms of dry weights. The only time that trailer is at 'dry weight' is taking it home the first time.
Having questioned the eighty percent rule and agree totally with you about not knowing exactly what somebody's trailer really weighs, I don't send a boy to do a man's job. I tow a Pacific Coachworks 299bhs Tango trailer with a turbo diesel one-ton truck. Needless to say, it works very well. It goes without saying I don't 'fall on my face' climbing hills. And I even have a tongue scale to be sure I am in the 13 percent ball park. While I find little comfort in the 80 percent rule, I think that a 30+ foot trailer warrants considerable thought about what will be used to tow it. I like plenty of reserve power, rated sea level power at alitiude in the mountains that comes with a turbo diesel, and 19+ mpg not towing so I drive my signature truck. Everywhere I tow, there are long grades up to eight percent for as many as seven or eight miles without a break, leaving Reno for Sacramento is a mostly steady 35 mile climb to Truckee, then another eight miles of steeper clmbing to Donner summit at 7300 feet. Diesels are incredibly popular around here as the hills are flattened by the engine. It is the long long hills that really shows whether the manufacturer has the tow ratings dialed in or if it is sales hype.
Power wise your TV does not know the difference between an 8,000lb 25ft TT or an 8,000lb 30ft TT. You may be a little more susceptible to cross winds but power wise there is no effect. Weight and frontal area are weight and frontal area regardless of length.
Smoke 05 Titan SE CC 4X4
K&N panel filter
PRG 2.5" Leveling kit
Bilstein front,Icon rear shocks
Powerstop slotted rotors
18" Wrangler AT/S LT's
2009 Fleetwood Prowler 2702BS
Primus Brake Controller
Reese DC w/ 1,000lb/10,000lb WD
|
ejbrandley

Entirely too young to be a

Senior Member

Joined: 06/18/2007

View Profile

Offline
|
jmtandem wrote: ej,
Nice sarcasism but seriously your are under in your tongue weight. If you are really at 8000 pounds trailer weight, the tongue should be 10-15 percent or 800 to about 1200 pounds. Good luck and happy towing.
i might be light or maybe i'm not i got no sway at all with no sway bar hooked up doing 60 to 65 with semis flying bye me and in all honesty my whole rig really didnt move much even with cross winds .....i know with my old pop up if i had the tongue eight off bye say maybe 25 30 pounds then it would make for a very long miserable ride the darn thing would sway at 45 mph and it was a 12 foot box that weighed close to 3k
|
bobbyg123

Duvall, WA

Senior Member

Joined: 10/03/2007

View Profile

Offline
|
DavidP wrote: I agree! Anything over 26 Feet you need atleast an F350
dually.
HAHA Well played
2008 Jayfeather 29A
2007 Ford F-150 5.4L V8
|
jmtandem

carson city nv

Senior Member

Joined: 01/18/2006

View Profile

Offline
|
Keith,
Again, you are correct. My observation was based on the fact that usually the larger/longer trailer and /or those with sildes are heavier. Therefore, a 30 foot trailer would likely be heavier than a 20 foot trailer but as you point out, that is not always the case and the engine of the truck doesn't care how long a trailer is, just how heavy. Good eye and thanks for calling that to my attention.
|
Fisherguy

BC Canada

Senior Member

Joined: 07/31/2003

View Profile

|
DavidP wrote:
I agree! Anything over 26 Feet you need atleast an F350
dually.
Now that's funny!
While I agree towing a 30 ft trailer with a half ton is a little unwise. saying you need a dually to tow anything more than a 26 ft trailer is a bit of a stretch.
06 Dodge Ram 3500 Cummins 6 spd std with a few mods.
2007 Komfort 274TS
|
|
|