cancel
Showing results forย 
Search instead forย 
Did you mean:ย 

What can I do with/expect from a generator?

rvshrinker
Explorer III
Explorer III
We have boondocked four days easily without, but for skiing this winter and possibly up to one week of boondocking... Saw a used Honda 3000ec available for $750. What will that do for us? How long do I need to run something like that the charge our batteries up? I have two 6v batteries.
36 REPLIES 36

Jebby14
Explorer
Explorer
where are you skiing? I suspect taking the trailer will cost more than the holiday inn off site.
Q: Whats brown and sticky???

A: A Stick....

Gjac
Explorer III
Explorer III
rvshrinker wrote:
We have boondocked four days easily without, but for skiing this winter and possibly up to one week of boondocking... Saw a used Honda 3000ec available for $750. What will that do for us? How long do I need to run something like that the charge our batteries up? I have two 6v batteries.
Look at the bigger picture, your profile says you have a travel trailer, how many gals of FW does your tank hold? If it is 50 gals or less that will be your limiting factor especially if you have not dry camped before with your wife. A Buddy heater as Bud suggested uses no battery power and will heat a small trailer. With two 6 V GC batteries with lights, water pump, refer on propane mine will last 7 days before they reach 50% SOC and with 60 gals of FW my water tank will be empty. I don't know what other electrical requirement you have. If you take showers every day you will probably use your water up in 5 days or less. Can you get FW in the winter where you ski, how big is your grey tank? Can you dump at the ski area? Not knowing the details of how you camp or your electrical needs it is hard to say if you need a genset or not. My guess you will run out of water before you run out of battery power.

K3WE
Explorer
Explorer
philh wrote:
K3WE wrote:
Edit: Also, arguably you probably don't want to heat water with a generator when boon-docking. Probably better to use LP.

If the generator is already running, AND you have capacity, why wouldn't you use electric to heat water?


You saw the words 'arguably' and 'probably' in my post, right?

It's rather inefficient to burn gas to make electricity to heat water versus burning gas to heat water directly. Gas engines are pretty inefficient.

That being said, you CAN do it as you say, and maybe filling the gasoline tank is easier than filling the LP tank, so efficiency doesn't matter, but not using electricity to heat water can help you get by with a smaller generator...

Lots of trade offs to tip the scale one way or another, but it is less efficient.

rvshrinker
Explorer III
Explorer III
Yeah thatโ€™s the generator. Iโ€™ll pass on it.

In the near future I donโ€™t see a need for a 3000w generator because we donโ€™t need ac. We live in the pacific northwest and if we go east of the mountains in summer weโ€™ll be hooked up. If down the road that changes I can get bigger.

So for now a 2000 watt if I want to run the heater in the winter (while skiing) and sometimes the microwave?

Weโ€™ve been on about 16 trips and a total of 60 days in almost two years and only run the AC for about 3 hours one day.

I checked the batteries and the water is full. No evidence of boil off. Weโ€™ve boondocked 4 days and had 2/3 of battery power left. So far no problem with staying plugged in. If I donโ€™t stay plugged in, what is the solution? Isnโ€™t it also unhealthy to have the batteries discharge?

pianotuna
Nomad II
Nomad II
While part timing I would often heat the water electrically as I was trundling down the road. I used a duty cycle of ten minutes heating, and twenty minutes off. It worked well for me.
Regards, Don
My ride is a 28 foot Class C, 256 watts solar, 556 amp-hours of Telcom jars, 3000 watt Magnum hybrid inverter, Sola Basic Autoformer, Microair Easy Start.

philh
Explorer II
Explorer II
K3WE wrote:
Edit: Also, arguably you probably don't want to heat water with a generator when boon-docking. Probably better to use LP.

If the generator is already running, AND you have capacity, why wouldn't you use electric to heat water?

full_mosey
Explorer
Explorer


This?

aftermath
Explorer II
Explorer II
rvshrinker wrote:
That's an interesting link, over my head a lot of it... I have left our rig plugged into a 110 socket for months at a time. It runs the fridge and LED lights and in the winter the furnace on subfreezing nights, maybe 20 nights per year. Battery panel always says fully charged but I've never tried to look in closer detail. I've also never, gulp, checked the water level. Have had rig almost two years. I'll try to figure that out today.

We are building a true 30 and 50 amp hookup this summer.


When I first read this I interpreted "for months at a time" as basically meaning always hooked up. Before I did any winter camping I would have those batteries checked. Here is what happened to me. We bought our trailer used and the PO left it plugged in all the time. The converter was constantly overcharging the batteries and they were shot. When we looked at it, everything was working just fine and the monitor showed fully charged batteries. On the way home we stayed overnight and plugged it in. On our first dry camping trial it all came home, we had two bad batteries and a bad converter too. As long as you are hooked up your batteries will always show full charge. Unplug the trailer and wait a few hours and then check them.

So, to charge batteries you don't need a big generator but you do need a good converter and two good batteries. We have a Honda 2000 and a few hours a day works for us.
2017 Toyota Tundra, Double Cab, 5.7L V8
2006 Airstream 25 FB SE
Equalizer Hitch

BillyBob_Jim
Explorer
Explorer
SoundGuy wrote:
rvshrinker wrote:
Saw a used Honda 3000ec available for $750.


bikendan wrote:
That's a great price for a Honda 3000i.


Problem is, the OP didn't say it was an EU3000i or even an EU3000iS so we really don't know what genset the OP is talking about. AFAIK there's no such thing as a Honda "3000ec" ... who knows, maybe it's an open frame genset. It's also hard to believe anyone would be selling an EU3000i or EU3000iS for just $750.


An EC3000 is a contractor style conventional generator, not an inverter.
The EC was not made for sale in the US.

It will charge the OP's batteries fine as long as he can put up with the racket. Personally I would get a real long cord to deal with that, about 4000' should do nicely LOL.

K3WE
Explorer
Explorer
I don't know that it matters a whole lot for WINTERTIME use...Yeah don't run too many heat appliances at the same time (Microwave, coffee maker, hair drier)...but nice 'small' quiet 2000 watt generators should run those things and charge batteries.

To run an air conditioner- THEN you have some requirements.

Edit: Also, arguably you probably don't want to heat water with a generator when boon-docking. Probably better to use LP.

PhilipB
Explorer
Explorer
I'll assume the gen for sale is the quiet version. That said, we've found that it's easier to run a small electric cube heater. Easier to refill the gas can, rather than propane. We have a 3000 and it'll run 30 hours in a weekend during the summer if we are using A/C. Other than feeding it gas, it works great.

If you have a source for propane, then you'll just need to re-charge batteries and run it when you need a/c.

High altitude will degrade output.
2015 Ram 2500
[purple]2013 Raptor 310TS[/purple]

pianotuna
Nomad II
Nomad II
Hi valhalla,

Ty for pointing that out.

Sorry I was not clear--these numbers are from my RV--but I think that most units have similar draws.

So far as I am aware the only microwave that uses inverter technology to allow lower power levels is Panasonic. The others (and mine) merely pulse on and off to slow the cooking process.

I "get around" brief over loads by using the "load support" feature on my hybrid inverter. But be aware load support is NOT voltage support, so it still behooves the end user to monitor what is going on.


valhalla360 wrote:
pianotuna wrote:
Hi,

The microwave draws 1561 watts and the water heater 1400. Adding in the fridge is another 325 watts. One would have to rely on the water heater and fridge being in the off part of their duty cycle, or there might be quite a bit of voltage drop.


The advantage is the ability to run the roof air conditioner.

valhalla360 wrote:
Reality, is you can run the microwave, TV & fridge simultaneously. Possibly the water heater but that's pushing it a bit.


That's awfully specific...where did he list the microwave model? Some microwaves go that high but I've also seen smaller 600-800w models and you can use lower power settings.

But as I said, running microwave and water-heater simultaneously gets iffy...even at 800 + 1400 if the charger kicks on at 50amp/12v...you are pushing the limits of a 3000w generator...which is likely rated for a lower amount in continuous duty.

3000w is plenty for air/con. We run on a 2600w yamaha. (no, not with microwave and hot water heater but TV, fridge and lights we've never had a problem).
Regards, Don
My ride is a 28 foot Class C, 256 watts solar, 556 amp-hours of Telcom jars, 3000 watt Magnum hybrid inverter, Sola Basic Autoformer, Microair Easy Start.

valhalla360
Nomad
Nomad
pianotuna wrote:
Hi,

The microwave draws 1561 watts and the water heater 1400. Adding in the fridge is another 325 watts. One would have to rely on the water heater and fridge being in the off part of their duty cycle, or there might be quite a bit of voltage drop.


The advantage is the ability to run the roof air conditioner.

valhalla360 wrote:
Reality, is you can run the microwave, TV & fridge simultaneously. Possibly the water heater but that's pushing it a bit.


That's awfully specific...where did he list the microwave model? Some microwaves go that high but I've also seen smaller 600-800w models and you can use lower power settings.

But as I said, running microwave and water-heater simultaneously gets iffy...even at 800 + 1400 if the charger kicks on at 50amp/12v...you are pushing the limits of a 3000w generator...which is likely rated for a lower amount in continuous duty.

3000w is plenty for air/con. We run on a 2600w yamaha. (no, not with microwave and hot water heater but TV, fridge and lights we've never had a problem).
Tammy & Mike
Ford F250 V10
2021 Gray Wolf
Gemini Catamaran 34'
Full Time spliting time between boat and RV

pianotuna
Nomad II
Nomad II
Hi,

The microwave draws 1561 watts and the water heater 1400. Adding in the fridge is another 325 watts. One would have to rely on the water heater and fridge being in the off part of their duty cycle, or there might be quite a bit of voltage drop.

I too, would favor the Predator 3500 with electric start.

The advantage is the ability to run the roof air conditioner.

valhalla360 wrote:
Reality, is you can run the microwave, TV & fridge simultaneously. Possibly the water heater but that's pushing it a bit.
Regards, Don
My ride is a 28 foot Class C, 256 watts solar, 556 amp-hours of Telcom jars, 3000 watt Magnum hybrid inverter, Sola Basic Autoformer, Microair Easy Start.