โMar-14-2019 08:46 AM
โMar-21-2019 06:26 PM
โMar-21-2019 06:14 PM
โMar-21-2019 06:06 PM
94-D2 wrote:
my experience is localized and not national which is why you canโt find it on the internet. I am simply relating two experiences I had personally in the course of my duties as it related to the OP. so your skepticism is all yours. Take what you want from it but you donโt have to be belittling or rude. I was looking at the forum to augment my new 5th wheel and pull truck and ran across the post. Thatโs it. It am not an internet troller hel bent baiting unsuspecting people into arguments. have no grandiose need to be regarded or see my post in print to get off on it. Iโm an officer of the law and as such carry the character and integrity required of the position. It is obvious that this forum is either fraternal and closed to those not in the click or plain uninviting; if you are representing yourself as a senior member on this forum. Either way, it is apparent some people arenโt welcome. So, have an admin delete my bogus post and go ahead with your life.
To the OP, my experiences are intended to inform you of what I observed regarding the hitch. Good luck and safe travels with whatever you do with your RV. I wish you well.
โMar-21-2019 06:01 PM
โMar-21-2019 09:50 AM
ependydad wrote:WTP-GC wrote:
This should be interesting...
The entire internet can offer maybe 2-3 examples of supposed failure of the AUH, none of which involved a collision. Now a brand new forum member shows up and has 2 exclusive examples by himself. If the "pyramid structure" failed, that hardly means that the trailer would have come dislodged from the coupler or ball. In fact, no other report has shown an absolute failure of the frame...only deflection of the members.
Accident reports are public record. Please provide a link to the reports.
I followed a thread on a Toy Hauler group on Facebook where owners posted about their crash and the AUH failing. The owners claim the AUH failed during a hard braking maneuver but also admit to following too closely. Timing is so quick in a crash that it's hard to say for certain.
Here's a copy of the pictures and their write-up (it's Facebook, but you don't have to login to see them):
https://www.facebook.com/LearnToRV/posts/1882493731818038?__xts__%5B0%5D=68.ARDLZOLXq1fXRN9-7ct_kdrz...
The owners sent the mangled hitch back to Andersen but never heard anything back from them.
This was the "new and improved" design.
โMar-21-2019 09:00 AM
ependydad wrote:
I'll admit, this is all the farther I've made it into this thread.BucknMindy wrote:
The idea of something much lighter is a selling factor also as well as the smooth ride.
The ride was the exact reason that I got rid of my Andersen. With my truck and trailer combination, it was so bad that my wife was in pain from it. She couldn't take back to back travel days.
I wrote a full review here:
http://learntorv.com/andersen-ultimate/
I got the hitch so that I could do a direct head-to-head comparison to the B&W Companion since both hitches have fanatical fan bases:
http://learntorv.com/the-hitch-showdown/
โMar-21-2019 08:09 AM
WTP-GC wrote:
This should be interesting...
The entire internet can offer maybe 2-3 examples of supposed failure of the AUH, none of which involved a collision. Now a brand new forum member shows up and has 2 exclusive examples by himself. If the "pyramid structure" failed, that hardly means that the trailer would have come dislodged from the coupler or ball. In fact, no other report has shown an absolute failure of the frame...only deflection of the members.
Accident reports are public record. Please provide a link to the reports.
โMar-21-2019 08:02 AM
BucknMindy wrote:
The idea of something much lighter is a selling factor also as well as the smooth ride.
โMar-21-2019 07:55 AM
โMar-21-2019 07:31 AM
โMar-21-2019 06:30 AM
โMar-21-2019 05:42 AM
โMar-21-2019 05:30 AM
WTP-GC wrote:94-D2 wrote:
That being said, I have had two experiences with the mentioned hitch system and both times was in the course of a collision investigation and both times the hitch failed at impact. Specifically, the pyramid structure did not hold up during the impact which resulted in the trailer striking the rear of pull vehicle cab. The last such case was an 8k TT/Ram 1500 hitting a Chevy S10 at 30 mph. The fist was a 12k Terry/Ford combination that hit a Miata rear end. Those two instances alone, would shy me away from this style of hitch and stick with the 5th wheel.
It is my underatanding that B&W makes a 5th wheel hitch that fits its center bed box. I would certainly look into that instead.
This should be interesting...
The entire internet can offer maybe 2-3 examples of supposed failure of the AUH, none of which involved a collision. Now a brand new forum member shows up and has 2 exclusive examples by himself. If the "pyramid structure" failed, that hardly means that the trailer would have come dislodged from the coupler or ball. In fact, no other report has shown an absolute failure of the frame...only deflection of the members.
Accident reports are public record. Please provide a link to the reports.
โMar-21-2019 03:23 AM
94-D2 wrote:
That being said, I have had two experiences with the mentioned hitch system and both times was in the course of a collision investigation and both times the hitch failed at impact. Specifically, the pyramid structure did not hold up during the impact which resulted in the trailer striking the rear of pull vehicle cab. The last such case was an 8k TT/Ram 1500 hitting a Chevy S10 at 30 mph. The fist was a 12k Terry/Ford combination that hit a Miata rear end. Those two instances alone, would shy me away from this style of hitch and stick with the 5th wheel.
It is my underatanding that B&W makes a 5th wheel hitch that fits its center bed box. I would certainly look into that instead.